Unsolved Mysteries Rewind – Episode 12: Dale Kerstetterm, Orphan Train, Marfa Lights, The Deaths of Jay Cook & Tanya Cuylenborg

Listen Directly

In this episode Kim and Mark discuss Season 2, Episode 5 of Unsolved Mysteries.

  • Missing Persons: Dale Kerstetter
  • Updates: Orphan Train
  • The Unexplained: Marfa Lights
  • Unexplained Death: Jay Cook and Tanya Van Cuylenborg
  • Wanted: Salvatore Caruana

Join us this week as we break down the mysterious disappearance of Dale Kerstetter, hop aboard the orphan train, and uncover the folklore behind the Marfa lights. We also dive into the first case that harnessed the power of genetic genealogy, and discuss what may have happened to Salvatore Caruana.


As always, thank you to Mat Graham from Artificial Fear for allowing us to use his amazing cover of the Unsolved Mysteries Theme Song! Check out his YouTube Channel here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCoQNyGGSIl_ZbEDq-teZDWQ

And thank you to Ryan Hughes from Planet H for lending us his spot-on “Stack Voice” and working with us to have such a cool intro and outro! Check out his YouTube Channel here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCYrlNAFRMlWQN1rhWboZh2g


Leave a Reply